The Films of 2008: Part Three

4. No Country for Old Men (Joel & Ethan Coen)

A meditation on the fickle nature of fate? A parable-like story of good versus evil? A lesson in how not to wear one’s hair? All this and more in this, a superb return to form for the brothers Coen, intermingling their well-known trademarks (black humour, a host of oddball characters) with the Cormac McCarthy source story to create a hugely entertaining romper of a thriller, but with enough brains to placate the arthouse set. Props also to both DP Roger Deakins and composer Carter Burwell for their remarkable yet easy-to-overlook contributions to the feel of the film.

3. 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days (Cristian Mungiu)

The Palme D’or winner at last year’s Cannes, 4 Months… is a grim polemic showing what the criminalization of abortion can lead people to do out of necessity. Sparely shot, though uncompromisingly graphic when it needs to be, director Mungiu demonstrates a remarkable control over both narrative flow and audience tension, whilst the two female leads give superb, and very different performances: in particular, the fearful resolve of Anamaria Marinca to get through their ordeal. Filmmaking at its most powerful.

The Films of 2008: Part Two

7. El Orfanato (Juan Antonio Bayona)

Whilst borrowing from horror both classic (The Innocents) and more recent (The Others, producer Guillermo Del Toro’s The Devil’s Backbone), Bayona’s debut film is a worthy addition to cinema’s haunted house canon: visually and sonically striking, economically constructed, and with a superb central performance from Belen Rueda as a woman reconciling herself with grief both past and present. Haunting, unsettling and deeply moving, one of the best chillers of recent years.

6. Waltz with Bashir (Ari Folman)

Animated documentary, a bold aesthetic choice of form, examining Israeli filmmaker Folman’s (and his country’s as a whole) amnesia of his role in the events which led to the Sabra and Shatila massacre in Lebanon in 1982. Superb in its balancing off of realism and its more fantastical flights of fancy, it stands as a distinctive, thoroughly engaging and thought-provoking piece of work, and one which will surely considerably influence the documentary form for many years to come.

5. Hunger (Steve McQueen)

Truly remarkable debut feature from British visual artist McQueen, centring on the events in the Maze Prison in Northern Ireland in the early 1980s which notoriously led up to the death of IRA member Bobby Sands, yet with clear reference to the current political climate. Demonstrating both a distinctive visual style and an impressive filmmaking range, the film clearly points to greatness in the future for the director. On balance, I was overly critical in my initial assessment of the film: for its trivial faults (personal gripes on my part) it is undoubtedly the best British film of the year – visceral, uncompromising, daring, and considering its subject matter, surprisingly politically unbiased.

The Films of 2008: Part One

10. In Bruges (Martin McDonagh)

Colin Farrell is one of those actors who seems effortlessly to be able to convince you that he is truly dire and that he should not be allowed anywhere near a film set, let alone in front of the cameras. But there are times when he can be simply brilliant, and In Bruges is such an occasion. With a foul-mouthed script that fizzes along beautifully, coupled with yet another superb Brendan Gleeson performance, In Bruges is above all great fun, and hopefully marks out stage veteran Martin McDonagh as a new cinema director to watch.

9. The Diving Bell and the Butterfly (Julian Schnabel)

One of the most remarkable and touching books ever written is brought to the screen admirably by visual artist Schnabel, with no small thanks to the visual inventiveness of cinematographer extraordinaire Janusz Kaminski. The true story of Jean-Do Bauby, almost completely paralysed after a massive stroke, transcends its inherent tragedy and becomes both a story of individual self-reassessment, and a lesson to us all to be carefully examine how we all live our own lives.

8. Persepolis (Vincent Paronnaud, Marjane Satrapi)

Critics may point to its simplifications of a complex subject, but this misses the point: this is not a history of the Iranian Revolution, but an examination of one young girl’s experience of it, wrapped up in the narrative of a sometimes conventional coming-of-age bildungsroman. Satrapi, the author of the graphic novels on which the film is based, translates the aesthetic of the source material to create a perfectly cinematic expressionistic style of animation, and the story balances themes specific and the universal beautifully to create a very personal document of growing up, but one that we can all relate to on some level.

Le Silence de Lorna (Jean-Pierre & Luc Dardenne, 2008, Belgium / France / Italy / Germany)

The trouble with success, especially critical success, is the accompanying expectation that it brings. In the case of the Dardenne brothers, success equals the two Cannes Palmes D’or glistening atop their mantlepiece, and their status as one of the world’s premier filmmaking teams, but the resulting anticipation of whatever had to follow the hugely acclaimed L’Enfant (2006) has resulted in a bit of a critical mauling for their new film. Let’s get one thing straight: Le Silence de Lorna is certainly not terrible; it does, however, represent something of a departure from the brothers’ traditional terrain, which for many has clearly been hard to swallow.

At first, the situation seems like standard Dardennes fare: the titular Lorna is an Albanian working in a dry cleaners in the Belgian town of Liege. Her ‘silence’ is tied up to the situation she has gotten herself into: she is cohabiting and in a marriage of convenience with local junkie Claudy, she to acquire Belgian citizenship, he to take the financial incentive offered to him for such a deal. The wider plan is for them to divorce, and she to marry again to allow a presumably rich Russian man also to gain an EU passport. From the proceeds of this, Lorna and her actual boyfriend plan to settle down and open a snack bar in town.

On paper this all sounds a matter of paperwork, but the reality of the situation separates this from Green Card (1990) territory: deals are brokered in taxis through the menacing-looking small-time gangster Fabio, who from the off makes clear the absence of morals in the world which Lorna has gotten involved in. Though largely lacking in affection for her ‘husband’, she is naturally horrified at plans to give him a killer overdose in order to speed along her next sham marriage. What Fabio’s introduction into proceedings does is clearly define Le Silence de Lorna as a kind of morality play: how far is the seemingly benign, if rather misguided, Lorna willing to go to in search of her ambition?

The Dardennes’ screenplay succeeds best where it is posing these questions, and the strongest scenes are based on this: some blackly comic scenes where Lorna realizes what she must do in order to obtain a quickie divorce, and one memorably painful scene to watch in a seedy bar where she must slow-dance with her proposed Russian husband, set to some ultra-cheesy music. The constant changing hands of wads of Euro notes, a recurring motif, illustrates what is at root ultimately driving everything along. The problem is that in order to create the situations, some rather ill-judged plot contrivances have to be thrown in; despite for the majority of their screentime together Lorna being aloof to Claudy’s gestures of friendship, within a few short frames we are made to believe that she harbours a passion for him, whether physical or spiritual. Almost immediately afterwards, a major plot development occurs offscreen, and the film is suddenly turned on its head again.

This appears to be the major gripe that some viewers have had with the film, and in particular with the final minutes which seem counter to the apparent realism of the film up until that point. But this is to make a major misjudgement about what the Dardennes are doing: despite their strict adherence to a realist aesthetic and mise en scene, their film is not primarily about the harsh economic realities of New Europe, a la Ulrich Seidl’s Import/Export (2007) or Lukas Moodysson’s Lilya 4-Ever (2002), though this is clearly the context. What the film’s second half becomes is the kind of Bressonian cinematic poetry that should be an obvious reference to followers of the Dardennes’ prior work. If the rather clumsily-handled dramatic elements are the price we have to pay to see the brothers experiment with new forms and expand their range then so be it.

Great Films: Radio On (Christopher Petit, 1979, UK / West Germany)

When one thinks of a road movie, the images that instantly spring to mind are of endless journeys along long, dusty American highways, man and motor fused together amidst desolate, inhospitable surrounds, of Two Lane Blacktop (1971), Easy Rider (1969) or Vanishing Point (1971). What does not think of is the quiet, two-hour drive west from London to Bristol, but that is exactly what Radio On, the 1979 debut feature by film critic Christopher Petit, offers up instead. A reinvention of the road movie genre for England, it is a film with few precedents and no antecedents, but remains a fascinating portrait of a very particular place and time.

The story, for what it’s worth, concerns the Kafka-esque monickered Robert B, a late-night London DJ who receives news of his brother’s death in Bristol, and ostensibly sets out on a road trip to investigate the circumstances. Along the way, he stops off at a pub, picks up a hitchhiker, meets a man living in a caravan, eventually alighting in Bristol where he encounters and befriends a German lady estranged from her daughter. But what becomes evident early on from the almost entire absence of narrative thrust is that this is not a film about mystery or plot, but a mood piece, a piece of British arthouse cinema not ashamed to wear its European influences on its sleeve.

The most obvious debt, as is clear from as early on as the opening credits, is to Wim Wenders, associate producer of the movie, as well as its clear spiritual forefather. His German road movie trilogy, Alice in the Cities (1974), The Wrong Move (1975), and Kings of the Road (1976) is the obvious stylistic influence here, in particular the monochrome photography (Wenders loaned his own DP Robby Müller to Petit for the making of the film), but also the use of long shot lengths, allowing the camera to linger on scenes much longer than would be conventional, giving a feeling of melancholy reflection.

For a road movie, there is a remarkable lack of a sense of liberty — driving scenes are mostly confined to shots filmed from inside the vehicle, and the framing of the windscreen gives less of the impression of the freedom of the open road a la Easy Rider, but at times more like the trapped Marcello Mastroianni attempting to escape at the start of (1963). In this sense it is different from the Wenders films, and perhaps more reflecting the size of the British Isles — no road journey in one direction can last much longer than a few hours by definition, so how much a sense of freedom can there be?

One of the unusual aspects of the film is its unromanticized view of 1970s England. No criticism of the film I have yet read has not mentioned the adjective “Ballardian” to describe the early shots of the capital, a London not of the Ritz and Buckingham Palace, but of ugly industry, dreary tower-blocks, and somehow menacing motorway flyovers. These early shots, coupled with the later similar views of Bristol are oddly reminiscent of the Paris of Godard’s Alphaville (1965), or possibly the corner of Rome in Antonioni’s L’Eclisse (1962) — the use of contemporary architecture to predict a dystopian future.

More in common with the latter of these cinematic references, the film’s somewhat nightmarish urban geography gives us the context of the film’s making, Britain of the late 1970s, as do other cues: the Krautrock soundtrack of Kraftwerk and Berlin-era Bowie, the filtering in of new technologies such as audio cassettes and video games. Snippets of radio news reports offer the further context of ongoing IRA terrorist campaigns, anti-pornography raids, and violence underlying an England far removed from the austerity of the Fifties or the Swinging Sixties. If the film’s title is a reference to Jonathan Richman’s song Roadrunner, then it does not appear to share the singer’s being “in love with the modern world”.

This urban decay is in stark contrast to the pastoral countryside we see on the journey between the two cities, and the difference between these two Englands becomes a further point of interest. In a later scene, we enter an older lady’s very middle-class household, the formality of her matching china teacups the epitome of picture-postcard British bourgeois living, and in direct contrast to the lives of everybody else we have seen in the film so far. Radio On feels a companion piece to post-punk’s musical prediction of the civil unrest to follow under the Thatcher regime in the coming decade, in that it flags up the dichotomy between the vision of a supposed classless social ideal and the unfortunate reality of such a folly.

There is a wider point also here, regarding Britain’s place in the world. On the one hand, there are many references to the closeness with Europe, in particular Germany, not just in the score, the visual aesthetic, and the prominent presence of German actress Lisa Kreuze, but also in more subtle ways, for instance the quiet paralleling of experiences of IRA and Baader-Meinhof terrorism. Even the credits appear bi-lingual in both English and German. And given that this is an existential road movie, is not existentialism itself a strictly European invention? At the time, Britain was seeing rising Euro-scepticism, and perhaps the film was calling on people to move closer rather than pull away from their continental cousins.

Conversely, there are glimpses of America, much like we see in Wenders’ own Alice in the Cities (1974), but these seem strangely alien and forced. B encounters a man, played by none other than Sting, who lives in a caravan close to the spot where Eddie Cochran died in a car crash in 1960. He sings “Three Steps To Heaven,” but the juxtaposition of the song to the setting of a quiet road outside the village of Chippenham reduces it to the absurd. Later on, B admires the lines of a vintage Cadillac and sits in it, only to be told “it doesn’t suit you.” When he drinks – swigging from a can of Guinness at the wheel, a hip flask on a seaside pier, or a solitary pint in a pub – he lacks the cool sheen of Hollywood’s alcoholic anti-heroes.

If B lacks cinematic cool, then he is also lacking in many other respects; his detachment from any kind of emotional response, whether the death of his brother, the affections of a beautiful woman, or being beaten up in a pub position him closer to the Mersault of Camus’ L’Etranger than any of the Kafka protagonists his name would suggest. His very blankness does render him lacking in a certain degree of sympathy, though it does allow him to be a cipher to explore other characters’ behaviors and attitudes. He, like the film, appears to have come from nothing, and does not appear to lead towards anything.

One scene, and in particular one song, lingers more than others. A pub jukebox plays Wreckless Eric’s “Whole Wide Worldalmost in its entirety, while B just sits down and slowly finishes his pint. What does it mean? Seemingly nothing. The song, incidentally, is one of the greatest to emerge from the punk period, a deceptively simple song about being lonely but spurred on by hopes however impossible. Perhaps it offers a key to this film about trying to find something, but not knowing what that thing is or where to go about finding it.